1 year ago today, the Wanzhou Middle School two students Wanxin distinguish water, is speeding the way to lift up an old lady fall. Unexpectedly, the elderly and their children, said he was actually the hp pavilion dv8000 battery, successfully sued him, asked their parents for compensation.
Due to insufficient evidence, the court of first instance dismissed the claims of the elderly, the elderly and their children appealed to the City, the Second Intermediate People's Court. Hearing this day, the old man offered to withdraw a lawsuit.
Although Yingliaoguansi, 1 year later, Wan Xi did not do good to come out from the shadows. He has always been honest to become even more boring than in the past, scores declined.
Save the fall for the elderly
Hand, a defendant
November 14, 2009, Wanzhou distinguish water two days of high school boys 15 years old Wan Xi, Li Town soaring to Wanzhou village to attend meetings. 2 pm, go home alone after Wanxin ganchang.
Wan Xi said, when he heard behind him a while, "ouch" sound, a look back two meters away an old woman to the ground, are groaning with pain.
Wan Xi said he ran to the elderly propped up, and asked her serious not serious. However, the old man grabbed him, and said he knocked her down. Wanxin a mouth Nanbian.
Stall in the street repair LEUNG Mo Wan Xi mother who heard and found that old people are arguing Wanxin and injury. To prevent accidents, and she quickly checked with the elderly to soaring health clinics, and for the elderly paid 65 inspection fee. Old man wounded in the leg that night, Mo repairs to the elderly Finland Wanzhou District Hospital for treatment. Elderly hospital 19 days later, Mo repair Finland 2 million yuan for medical expenses.
The elderly during hospitalization, elderly parents, relatives asked Wanxin lose money. As Wan Xi insists that he is doing good, no butt, Wanxin parents refused the other requirements.
March 11 this year, the elderly will be reported to the Wan Xi Wanzhou District People's Court, seeks compensation for medical expenses, care, hospital food subsidies, these payments totaled 30,483.5 yuan.
Number of witnesses
Proof of innocence juvenile
This year April 16, Wanzhou District People's Court held a public hearing this from the interesting hp pavilion dv8 battery.
Done something good, but Cheng Beigao, many people encounter Mingbu Ping Wan Xi. Hearing this day, we voluntarily to the court to give evidence for the Wan Xi. To attend classes because of Wanxin, Wan Xi's parents for him to appear.
Zhang elderly people injured, 77-year-old, is the town after the village in Wanzhou District. This day, the old man to find a good witness to appear for her, Lee did not testify.
Court held that the plaintiff in the soaring street near hospitals fell in front of, opposite the plaintiff the defendant walking back about two meters, lift up the plaintiff, the plaintiff put the defendant seized the edge are not allowed to go. The witnesses did not appear in court, and no other evidence to support, so the plaintiff is not sufficient evidence to prove the defendant hit the plaintiff.
The elderly claim was dismissed.
Wan Xi Liang as the father of million, said the court decision has put the whole family was very pleased. But then, the elderly Youxiang City Intermediate People's Court of Appeal. Wan Xi and parents again in the maelstrom of public opinion.
Witness return Xinjiang
Solidarity with the innocent young
"I Waer is innocent, please good people stand up, as he testified." An appeal for the elderly, Wanxin parents everywhere looking for more witnesses.
So far it's Wanzhou people working in Xinjiang Tan Xiangxuan know. In order to recover the innocent children, he quit his job, his own money, take the train back to Wanzhou.
Tan Xiangxuan that time of the incident, he was at the scene, saw the elderly is their fall. At that time, the elderly grasp and hold the child, his spot on the behavior of the elderly expressed dissatisfaction.
Elderly fall soon, Tan Xiangxuan to Xinjiang to work. I heard good things kids do when wronged the defendant, Tan Xiangxuan out of conscience and solidarity with the innocent children to go home.
The day of the second instance court
Active withdrawal of the elderly
August 3, Municipal Intermediate People's Court judge hearing the case blue light Huakai Ting. However, the elderly and their families has not yet been to the scene.
Lan Dial-old children Guanghua, the other said they do not want to appeal, and to withdrawal.
That day, a young man claiming to old grandson, covered with fingerprints sent a written withdrawal request. That said, the elderly Wanxin knocked down, because no evidence, so do not want to litigate. He said that this fingerprint the elderly.
This is the real old mean? Bright blue to bring the clerk, sat two or three hours by car, to verify the elderly.
Proved that the elderly do want to withdraw a lawsuit. She still insisted, "is that students Waer (of Wan Xi) I hit." She said, could not find evidence of her family do not want to pull it out. Subsequently, several children in the elderly on the signed withdrawal request.
Wan Xi ignited the issue when the defendant eventually settled through hp pavilion dv7 battery.
Dialogue Wanxin father
"He secretly hiding in the yard crying"
1 year later, the parties now? Attempts to reach the elderly and their relatives fall, without success.
Yesterday, the reporter contacted his father, Wan Wan Xi Liang Cheng.
Reporter: so what's the matter of the child?
Million Liang Cheng: He used to compare open, since that incident, he became silent, scores declined. On several occasions, I also found him hiding under the house secretly cried. Han asked him cry, he said: "You do not mean to be helpful?"
Reporter: Will you tell him to do the next thing?
Million Liang Cheng: That is affirmative. Days of the end of its own justice in, the good rewarded. I hope his son continues to do good.
Dialogue Wanxin
"I want it all day long"
Reporter: You said the old man knocked her down.
Wan Xi: no. I holds her up. I am innocent.
Reporter: this thing, how do you think?
Wan Xi: society is too complex.
Journalists; I heard your performance down a lot?
Wan Xin: I think about it all day long in class but also distracted, could not sleep at night, I fear that other people said I was bad. I actually have done something good.
Journalists; the future someone falls down, you will hand to help people?
Wan Xin: Yes! However, should figure it out before, so getting into hp pavilion dv6 battery.
Judge recommended
Also talk about ways to save
Judge Bright said Lan, Wan Xi doing good, but it became the defendant, if the court sentenced him to lose money, not only is the Wan Xi an injury, so his life in the future is hard to determine right and wrong, will also affect the social atmosphere, In the future, who would dare to do a good thing?
He said the Samaritan, helping others is a virtue, good deed done when the defendant in order to avoid the public in the rescue, please note the following:
When there are witnesses, the best known one or two helpers, and go and help others. Also shouted "Someone falls (injury)," and to remind others to pay attention.
The first alarm, waiting to be rescued in time the formation of evidence.
News Links
● 2006 年 11 On 20 April, Yu Peng, Nanjing youth propped up at the bus stop, Xu Granny falls, and take her to hospital. Do not want to, Xu and his family learned of her Granny fractures, to spend several million medical time-consuming, hit Peng Yu conclude that people want him to bear the medical expenses. Was rejected, Xu Granny to the court to require compensation for the loss of Peng Yu 13 million yuan. The trial court for a compensation 45,876 yuan Peng Yu, payment within 10 days. Peng Yu refused to accept an appeal. Ultimately, both reconciliation.
● 2006, 11 day of the month, villagers in Shandong Pingyin Ding Mou bike traffic along State Road 220, the case of Wang motorcycle approaching from behind. Wang said that when he was riding about 5 meters beyond the Ding Mou, Ding Mou found in the rearview mirror fall, cut back, and call 120. Unexpectedly, Ding Mou later successfully sued hp pavilion dv5 battery, saying that would be the one hanging on his motorcycle injury claim. Due to insufficient evidence, the court rejected the claims of Ding Mou.
没有评论:
发表评论